| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Dunlap-84, Fred | 1880-USA_NJ_PA_1 1880_USA_NJ_PA_1 | 348 |
| Stovey-88, Harry | 1880-USA_NJ_PA_1 1880_USA_NJ_PA_1 | 332 |
| Poorman-87, Tom | 1880-USA_NJ_PA_1 1880_USA_NJ_PA_1 | 324 |
| Shafer-84, Orator | 1880-USA_NJ_PA_2 1880_USA_NJ_PA_2 | 306 |
| Stearns-89, Dan | 1880-USA_NY_1 1880_USA_NY_1 | 294 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Radbourn-84, Old Hoss | 1880-USA_NY_2 1880_USA_NY_2 | 555 |
| Welch-85, Mickey | 1880-USA_NY_1 1880_USA_NY_1 | 520 |
| Galvin-84, Pud | 1880-USA_CA_MDW 1880_USA_CA_MDW | 490 |
| Bradley-76, George | 1880-USA_NJ_PA_2 1880_USA_NJ_PA_2 | 455 |
| Spalding-75, Al | 1880-USA_CA_MDW 1880_USA_CA_MDW | 445 |