| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Duffy-94, Hugh | 1890-USA_CT_MA_RI 1890_USA_CMR | 372 |
| Browning-87, Pete | 1890-USA_S_SE 1890_USA_SSE | 299 |
| Delahanty-99, Ed | 1890-USA_IN_MI_OH 1890_USA_IMO | 294 |
| O'Neill-87, Tip | 1890-Asia-Canada-Europe 1890_ACE | 293 |
| Ryan-88, Jimmy | 1890-USA_CT_MA_RI 1890_USA_CMR | 290 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Young-92, Cy | 1890-USA_IN_MI_OH 1890_USA_IMO | 335 |
| Stivetts-92, Jack | 1890-USA_NE_1 1890_USA_NE1 | 325 |
| Sweeney-84, Charlie | 1890-Asia-Canada-Europe 1890_ACE | 310 |
| Baldwin-86, Lady | 1890-USA_NY 1890_USA_NY | 305 |
| Nichols-98, Kid | 1890-USA_Midwest 1890_USA_MW | 300 |