| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Kelley-96, Joe | 1900-Northeast 1900_USA_NE | 350 |
| Seymour-05, Cy | 1900-NY_PA_2 1900_NY_PA_2 | 328 |
| Wallace-01, Bobby | 1900-NY_PA_2 1900_NY_PA_2 | 319 |
| Williams-99, Jimmy | 1900-Midwest 1900_USA_MW | 316 |
| Keeler-97, Willie | 1900-NY_PA_1 1900_NY_PA_1 | 310 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Chesbro-04, Jack | 1900-Northeast 1900_USA_NE | 255 |
| Mathewson-05, Christy | 1900-NY_PA_2 1900_NY_PA_2 | 255 |
| Dinneen-02, Bill | 1900-NY_PA_2 1900_NY_PA_2 | 240 |
| Taylor-02, Jack W | 1900-OHIO 1900_USA_OH | 210 |
| Dunn-99, Jack | 1900-NY_PA_2 1900_NY_PA_2 | 190 |