| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Cree-11, Birdie | 1910-USA_PA_2 1910_USA_PA_2 | 296 |
| Baker-12, Home Run | 1910-USA_S_SE_2 1910_USA_SSE_2 | 293 |
| Jackson-11, Shoeless Joe | 1910-USA_S_SE_2 1910_USA_SSE_2 | 287 |
| Carey-23, Max | 1910-USA_IL_IN_2 1910_IL_IN_2 | 280 |
| Milan-12, Clyde | 1910-USA_S_SE_1 1910_USA_SSE_1 | 279 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Walsh-08, Ed | 1910-USA_PA_2 1910_USA_PA_2 | 430 |
| Plank-04, Eddie | 1910-USA_PA_2 1910_USA_PA_2 | 300 |
| Camnitz-09, Howie | 1910-USA_S_SE_2 1910_USA_SSE_2 | 280 |
| Wiltse-08, Hooks | 1910-USA_NE_2 1910_USA_NE_2 | 225 |
| Brown-09, Mordecai | 1910-USA_IL_IN_2 1910_IL_IN_2 | 200 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Schulte-11, Frank | 1910-USA_NE_1 1910_USA_NE_1 | 321 |
| Speaker-12, Tris | 1910-USA_W_INTL_1 1910_WIN_1 | 308 |
| Wilson-12, Chief | 1910-USA_W_INTL_1 1910_WIN_1 | 277 |
| Magee-07, Sherry | 1910-USA_PA_1 1910_USA_PA_1 | 258 |
| Snodgrass-11, Fred | 1910-USA_W_INTL_1 1910_WIN_1 | 252 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Killian-07, Ed | 1910-USA_MI_WI 1910_USA_MWI | 295 |
| Vaughn-19, Hippo | 1910-USA_W_INTL_1 1910_WIN_1 | 295 |
| Tyler-18, Lefty | 1910-USA_NE_1 1910_USA_NE_1 | 245 |
| Joss-07, Addie | 1910-USA_MI_WI 1910_USA_MWI | 235 |
| Ford-10, Russ | 1910-USA_W_INTL_1 1910_WIN_1 | 225 |