| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Hornsby-22, Rogers | 1920-USA_Texas_West 1920_USA_TX_W | 439 |
| Sisler-20, George | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-2 1920_IN_OH_2 | 395 |
| Ruth-23, Babe | 1920-USA_Southeast 1920_USA_SE | 347 |
| Kenworthy-14, Duke | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-2 1920_IN_OH_2 | 311 |
| Williams-22, Ken | 1920-USA_Texas_West 1920_USA_TX_W | 309 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Luque-23, Dolf | 1920-California-International 1920_CA_INTL | 260 |
| Cadore-17, Leon | 1920-Illinois-Michigan-1 1920_IL_MI_1 | 205 |
| Eller-19, Hod | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-2 1920_IN_OH_2 | 175 |
| Davenport-15, Dave | 1920-USA_South 1920_USA_S | 170 |
| Cooper-20, Wilbur | 1920-USA_Southeast 1920_USA_SE | 150 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Kauff-14, Benny | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-1 1920_IN_OH_1 | 330 |
| Grimes-22, Ray | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-1 1920_IN_OH_1 | 316 |
| Frisch-27, Frankie | 1920-New York 1920_USA_NY | 293 |
| Burns-17, George J | 1920-New York 1920_USA_NY | 284 |
| Tobin-21, Jack | 1920-Kansas-Missouri 1920_KS_MO | 282 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Coveleski-20, Stan | 1920-NewJersey-Pennsylvania-2 1920_NJ_PA_2 | 255 |
| Mogridge-21, George | 1920-New York 1920_USA_NY | 235 |
| Alexander-16, Pete | 1920-USA_Midwest 1920_USA_MW | 220 |
| Pfeffer-16, Jeff | 1920-Illinois-Michigan-2 1920_IL_MI_2 | 215 |
| Shocker-21, Urban | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-1 1920_IN_OH_1 | 215 |