| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Hornsby-22, Rogers | 1920-USA_Texas_West 1920_USA_TX_W | 387 |
| Sisler-20, George | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-2 1920_IN_OH_2 | 384 |
| Kenworthy-14, Duke | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-2 1920_IN_OH_2 | 326 |
| Meusel-21, Bob | 1920-California-International 1920_CA_INTL | 310 |
| McHenry-21, Austin | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-2 1920_IN_OH_2 | 269 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Eller-19, Hod | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-2 1920_IN_OH_2 | 340 |
| Gregg-11, Vean | 1920-USA_Texas_West 1920_USA_TX_W | 325 |
| Davenport-15, Dave | 1920-USA_South 1920_USA_S | 320 |
| Schupp-17, Ferdie | 1920-Kentucky-Tennessee 1920_KY_TN | 280 |
| Schneider-17, Pete | 1920-California-International 1920_CA_INTL | 270 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Kauff-14, Benny | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-1 1920_IN_OH_1 | 266 |
| Mostil-26, Johnny | 1920-Illinois-Michigan-2 1920_IL_MI_2 | 256 |
| Bancroft-21, Dave | 1920-USA_Midwest 1920_USA_MW | 242 |
| McManus-30, Marty | 1920-Illinois-Michigan-2 1920_IL_MI_2 | 230 |
| Burns-17, George J | 1920-New York 1920_USA_NY | 230 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Faber-21, Red | 1920-USA_Midwest 1920_USA_MW | 365 |
| Bedient-12, Hugh | 1920-New York 1920_USA_NY | 305 |
| Mogridge-21, George | 1920-New York 1920_USA_NY | 230 |
| Leonard-14, Dutch H | 1920-Indiana-Ohio-1 1920_IN_OH_1 | 215 |
| Hendrix-14, Claude | 1920-Kansas-Missouri 1920_KS_MO | 210 |