| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Manush-28, Heinie | 1930-Alabama-Mississippi 1930_USA_AM | 341 |
| Waner-27, Paul | 1930-USA_South 1930_USA_S | 309 |
| Ott-34, Mel | 1930-USA_South 1930_USA_S | 305 |
| Klein-32, Chuck | 1930-Indiana-Ohio 1930_IN_OH | 304 |
| Wright-25, Glenn | 1930-Kansas-Missouri 1930_KS_MO | 299 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Powell-28, Willie | 1930-Alabama-Mississippi 1930_USA_AM | 345 |
| Morris-28, Ed W | 1930-Alabama-Mississippi 1930_USA_AM | 300 |
| Lyons-27, Ted | 1930-USA_South 1930_USA_S | 295 |
| Hudlin-29, Willis | 1930-USA_South 1930_USA_S | 235 |
| Wyatt-41, Whit | 1930-GA_NC_SC 1930_GA_NC_SC | 215 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Wilson-30, Hack | 1930-USA_Northeast-1 1930_USA_NE1 | 438 |
| Herman-30, Babe | 1930-New York 1930_USA_NY | 405 |
| Gehrig-27, Lou | 1930-New York 1930_USA_NY | 396 |
| Greenberg-35, Hank | 1930-New York 1930_USA_NY | 379 |
| Cuyler-25, Kiki | 1930-Midwest 1930_USA_MW | 370 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Thomas-27, Tommy | 1930-USA_Southeast 1930_USA_SE | 425 |
| Trent-28, Ted | 1930-USA_Southeast 1930_USA_SE | 360 |
| Grove-31, Lefty | 1930-USA_Southeast 1930_USA_SE | 330 |
| Lucas-29, Red | 1930-Kentucky-Tennessee 1930_USA_KT | 280 |
| Johnson-32, Si | 1930-Illinois 1930_USA_IL | 255 |