| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Kluszewski-54, Ted | 1950-USA_Illinois 1950_USA_ILL | 306 |
| Campanella-53, Roy | 1950-USA_Northeast_4 1950_NE4 | 306 |
| Snider-54, Duke | 1950-USA_CAL_TEX_WES_1 1950_USA_CTW1 | 297 |
| Holmes-45, Tommy | 1950-USA_Northeast_2 1950_NE2 | 291 |
| Hodges-54, Gil | 1950-USA_Indiana_Ohio 1950_USA_INO | 286 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Shea-47, Spec | 1950-USA_Northeast_4 1950_NE4 | 280 |
| Antonelli-54, Johnny | 1950-USA_Northeast_4 1950_NE4 | 245 |
| Newcombe-56, Don | 1950-USA_Northeast_2 1950_NE2 | 230 |
| Spahn-47, Warren | 1950-USA_Northeast_3 1950_NE3 | 205 |
| Rush-52, Bob | 1950-USA_Midwest 1950_USA_MW | 180 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Kiner-49, Ralph | 1950-USA_CAL_TEX_WES_2 1950_USA_CTW2 | 367 |
| Musial-48, Stan | 1950-USA_Northeast_1 1950_NE1 | 357 |
| Thomson-51, Bobby | 1950-International 1950_INT | 311 |
| Sievers-57, Roy | 1950-USA_KAN_MSO_NEB 1950_USA_KMN | 307 |
| Bell-53, Gus | 1950-USA_South_1 1950_USA_S1 | 299 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Newsome-41, Dick | 1950-USA_Southeast_1 1950_USA_SE1 | 205 |
| Gornicki-42, Hank | 1950-USA_Northeast_1 1950_NE1 | 195 |
| Sain-48, Johnny | 1950-USA_South_2 1950_USA_S2 | 195 |
| Voiselle-44, Bill | 1950-USA_Southeast_1 1950_USA_SE1 | 190 |
| Maglie-51, Sal | 1950-USA_Northeast_1 1950_NE1 | 165 |