| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Mays-65, Willie | 1960-USA_ALA_LOU_MSP 1960_USA_ALM | 347 |
| Aaron-63, Hank | 1960-USA_ALA_LOU_MSP 1960_USA_ALM | 340 |
| Boyer-60, Ken | 1960-USA_IWA_MSO 1960_USA_IAM | 322 |
| Cepeda-67, Orlando | 1960-International 1960_INT | 320 |
| Kaline-55, Al | 1960-USA_Southeast 1960_USA_SE | 320 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Gibson-68, Bob | 1960-USA_Midwest 1960_USA_MW | 245 |
| Short-65, Chris | 1960-USA_Southeast 1960_USA_SE | 205 |
| Pascual-59, Camilo | 1960-International 1960_INT | 200 |
| Drabowsky-57, Moe | 1960-International 1960_INT | 190 |
| Wilson-66, Earl | 1960-USA_ALA_LOU_MSP 1960_USA_ALM | 170 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Robinson-62, Frank | 1960-USA_TEX_WES 1960_USA_TXW | 408 |
| Cash-61, Norm | 1960-USA_TEX_WES 1960_USA_TXW | 357 |
| Mathews-53, Eddie | 1960-USA_TEX_WES 1960_USA_TXW | 349 |
| Gentile-61, Jim | 1960-USA_California_1 1960_USA_CA1 | 322 |
| Davis-62, Tommy | 1960-USA_New_York 1960_USA_NY | 317 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Ellsworth-63, Dick | 1960-USA_TEX_WES 1960_USA_TXW | 295 |
| Koufax-66, Sandy | 1960-USA_New_York 1960_USA_NY | 280 |
| Bunning-66, Jim | 1960-USA_South 1960_USA_S | 250 |
| Jackson-64, Larry | 1960-USA_TEX_WES 1960_USA_TXW | 240 |
| Osteen-69, Claude | 1960-USA_South 1960_USA_S | 200 |