| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Lynn-79, Fred | 1980-Illinois-Indiana-Wisconsin 1980_USA_IIW | 405 |
| Yount-82, Robin | 1980-Illinois-Indiana-Wisconsin 1980_USA_IIW | 392 |
| Murphy-84, Dale | 1980-USA_West 1980_USA_W | 356 |
| Parker-78, Dave | 1980-Alabama-Louisiana-Mississippi 1980_USA_ALM | 351 |
| Henderson-90, Rickey | 1980-Illinois-Indiana-Wisconsin 1980_USA_IIW | 326 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Richard-79, J R | 1980-Alabama-Louisiana-Mississippi 1980_USA_ALM | 320 |
| Scott-86, Mike | 1980-California_1 1980_USA_CA1 | 255 |
| Halicki-77, Ed | 1980-New_Jersey-Pennsylvania 1980_USA_NJ_PA | 240 |
| Eckersley-78, Dennis | 1980-California_1 1980_USA_CA1 | 190 |
| Reuschel-77, Rick | 1980-Illinois-Indiana-Wisconsin 1980_USA_IIW | 180 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Rice-78, Jim | 1980-Florida-Georgia-South_Carolina 1980_USA_FGS | 345 |
| Lopes-79, Davey | 1980-USA_Northeast 1980_USA_NE | 298 |
| Easler-84, Mike | 1980-Michigan-Ohio 1980_USA_MIO | 294 |
| Evans-82, Dwight | 1980-California_2 1980_USA_CA2 | 286 |
| Oglivie-80, Ben | 1980-International 1980_INTL | 286 |
| Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| James-85, Bob | 1980-California_3 1980_USA_CA3 | 265 |
| Valenzuela-85, Fernando | 1980-International 1980_INTL | 235 |
| Rhoden-84, Rick | 1980-Florida-Georgia-South_Carolina 1980_USA_FGS | 205 |
| Soto-83, Mario | 1980-Dominican_Republic-Puerto_Rico 1980_DR_PR | 200 |
| Tanana-76, Frank | 1980-Michigan-Ohio 1980_USA_MIO | 160 |